Death by Chocolate

posted in: Archives, History, Kate Elms, Newspapers | 7


Update 16/09/14: an updated version of this post by Kate Elms can be found on the Keep blog

Our celebration of Valentine’s Day seems a harmless indulgence but a glance at the history books reminds us that love can be a dark and destructive force.

The chocolate Poisoner Christiana Edmunds
The chocolate Poisoner Christiana Edmunds

Local papers archived at Brighton History Centre describe in detail the case of Christiana Edmunds, convicted of murder in 1872. Her story shows how desire can lead to delusion, with fatal consequences.

Christiana was a respectable young woman who moved to Brighton in the 1860s. In 1869, she met and fell in love with Dr Charles Beard, a married man whose surgery on Grand Parade was not far from her home in Gloucester Place. Their romance is said to have lasted about a year, during which time they exchanged love letters, but in the summer of 1870, Dr Beard ended the affair.

Soon after, Christiana visited the doctor’s wife Emily, bringing a gift of chocolate creams. After eating one, Mrs Beard was sick and her husband, suspecting foul play, banished Christiana from their home. He said nothing to the police, however. People in the town continued to fall ill after eating sweets or chocolates, though none were seriously affected until four-year-old Sidney Barker died in June 1871. The chocolates he had been given were found to contain strychnine (a form of pesticide), but a verdict of accidental death was recorded.

Despite this tragedy, the poisonings continued. Prominent families were targeted and even Christiana herself claimed to have been a victim. The police had no leads and no way of reassuring the public, until Dr Beard told them of his suspicions. Christiana was arrested and charged, first with the attempted murder of Emily Beard and later with the murder of Sidney Barker.

The trial began in Brighton, where it caused a sensation, and was moved to the Old Bailey in January 1872. Witnesses came forward to testify that Christiana had sent children to buy chocolates from Maynard’s, a well-known confectioner in West Street; she then injected them with poison and returned them to the shop, claiming they were not what she required. Her goal was to kill Mrs Beard but, to divert attention from herself, she was obviously prepared to risk the lives of many others.

The Victorians were fascinated with tales of true crime and Christiana’s story contained all the key ingredients – criminality and passion, deceit and disguise, beneath a veneer of respectability. Dubbed ‘the chocolate cream poisoner’, she was found guilty of murder and, declared insane, was sent to Broadmoor, then a criminal lunatic asylum. Vain, coquettish and apparently showing no sign of remorse, she remained there until her death in 1907.

Kate Elms, History Centre Officer

7 Responses

  1. Kate Clarke

    I am currently writing a book on Christiana Edmunds and the Case of the Poisoned Chocolate Creams – there are a great many accounts in the contemporary press but no photographs. I am aware that photographs of Christiana were published in and around Brighton at the time of the Magistrates’s hearing in The Town Hall and later, at the time of her trial at the Old Bailey in January 1872. I am stuill searching in Colindale Newspaper Archive but have yet to find a photograph. Any information about photographs would be most helpful.

    • Emily Mayson

      Hi Kate – Did you ever have any luck with your search for a photo of Christiana? I am looking for the same thing. Any clues gratefully received! Thanks, Emily

      • Royal Pavilion & Brighton Museums

        Just spoken to Kate, and it seems that no photo of Christiana Edmunds has yet been found. It seems there is a lot of interest in the case at the moment, and a lot of researchers are searching for a photo.

        • Emily Mayson

          Thanks for the info. Hopefully if someone finds one, they will let us know! I did find this extract in a newspaper that suggests lots of photos did exist at the time, so there are probably some boxed up in people’s lofts somewhere – “Affidavits were made by several persons, in which it was stated… that photographs of the prisoner were exhibited in the windows at Brighton, Arundel, and other towns in Sussex, and purchased in large numbers…”

  2. Robert Short

    I am the owner of a medical journal called The Practitioner. While researching the life of our first Editor, Dr Frances E Anstie, I find that in in 1872, volume VIII pages124-127 he expresses his views on medical advice in this case. e.g. “Let the lawyers hang whom they please, or spare whom they please, in Heaven’s name; but it is rather too much to ask us doctors to falsify the whole experience of our lives by saying that a woman born of such a family as Christiana Edmunds, living disappointed of marriage up to near the most critical period of sexual life, is either physically or morally to be judged upon the standard of ordinary criminals.’

  3. Helen

    Just in case this is useful but probably has already seen as it’s some years since the question 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *